Showing posts with label Adrienne Rich. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Adrienne Rich. Show all posts

Thursday, April 24, 2014

Lest we forget?

Today, Friday 25 April, is Anzac Day.

The date marks marks the anniversary of the landing of New Zealand and Australian soldiers – the Anzacs – on the Gallipoli Peninsula in 1915. The aim was to capture the Dardanelles, the gateway to the Bosphorus and the Black Sea. At the end of the campaign, thousands of young men - and double the number of Turkish men than those from France and the British Empire - had died and Gallipoli was still held by its Turkish defenders. For the would-be invaders, it was a military defeat.

For the European powers, the Gallopli campaign was a sideshow in the main theatre of the First World War: the battles of Verdun, the Somme and Passchendaele on the Western Front pushed the number of casualties into the millions. But for Australians and New Zealanders, the campaign played a role in further developing a nascent sense of national identity apart from the British Empire. Today, Anzac Day commemorates all those who have died in battle and honours returned servicemen and women.

But as these servicemen and women die off, something intriguing is happening. Anzac Day is growing in popularity, rather than lessening. During the 1960s and 1970s, Anzac Day was a focus of anti-war protests. From the 1980s, however, it underwent a renaissance, and the number of younger people attending dawn services and commemorative parades has been steadily increasing:


Now, people remark on the number of young New Zealanders in the crowds. Some wear the medals their grandparents and great-grandparents won during war. There are now no veterans left from Gallipoli or the First World War. Bright Williams, who passed away in 2003, was the last, and the number of Second World War veterans becomes fewer each year. (' Modern Anzac Day', NZHistoryNet)

Furthermore, for New Zealanders on their OE, attending the Anzac Day dawn service on the Gallipoli peninsula has been elevated to the same kind of pantheon as running with the bulls in Pamplona or getting hammered at the Munich Oktoberfest: it is a rite of passage. On Anzac Day, the quiet peninsula is swamped by young Australians and New Zealanders, some of whose behaviour has been censured as disrespectful and reflecting poorly on their Anzac forebears. A 2012 Australian study found that Anzac Day was primarily seen as 'a party for drunk yobbos'. The dawn service at Anzac Cove is now so popular that attendance is decided by a ballot, and politicians and Prime Ministers also attend.

I have been part of this renaissance: as a young girl in the 1980s, I marched in the Anzac Day parade through the main straight of town, my Brownie pack trailing behind the returned servicemen and women, the cubs and the scouts, and just about everyone else; and as a expatriate living in the UK in 2000, I visited the Gallipoli peninsula (which is now a historical national park) - not on Anzac Day - while travelling in Turkey.  

The latter visit was an interesting experience: on arrival at Istanbul, the customs officer took one look at my passport and said 'Ah Anzac' with a big smile. The Turkish guide on the peninsula itself was very positive about the relationship between Turkey, Australia and New Zealand, telling us that since our countries' sons were buried there, they had become part of Turkey. And we learned that, no less than for Australia and New Zealand, Turkish involvement in the First World War had played a crucial role in national politics and national identity. The old Ottoman Empire was more or less overthrown by the end of the war, and the modern Republic of Turkey was established in 1922.  

The group that I travelled to the peninsula with were emotionally primed for the visit, not by a documentary, nor old soldiers telling their stories, nor footage from the First World War, but by the mostly-accurate-but-fictional  Mel Gibson film Gallipoli (1981). The people sitting behind me were transfixed, occasionally breaking off to murmur 'such a waste', and 'so awful', and 'bloody Poms'.  Of such fictions are national myths made.

In the 1990s I had a disagreement with my flatmate about the significance of Anzac Day. She was disgusted by the militarist and patriarchal values in which it seemed to glory. With two younger brothers, both in their late teens at the time, I found the idea of thousands of young men being slaughtered deeply upsetting, and thought the injunction 'lest we forget' was a profound statement against war transmitted from those who had directly experienced its horrors. Now, I think we were both partially right, but that there are still other elements in play.

In New Zealand, for example, I think it says something quite significant about cultural unease with New Zealand's actual national origins and originary warfare in the nineteenth century - a story of promises made, agreements broken, invasion and resistance, dispossession and alienation - that means modern New Zealanders seek, whether consciously or not, to make Anzac Day into a national day. Every year, it seems, the call to make Anzac Day our official national day, rather than Waitangi Day (which commemorates the signing of the Treaty of Waitangi) is repeated (see, for example, this opinion piece published just hours ago). The same rhetoric is repeated: Anzac Day is unifying, Waitangi day divisive.  

The call to unity is a call to subscribe to a totalising national narrative. The 2012 Australian study noted above sounded a note of caution: such unifying calls are also potentially divisive, particularly as the multicultural composition of the nation increases. What of those 'new' New Zealanders and Australians who don't share this history? What is their place in this national narrative or does this dominant national narrative say that there is no place here for them?

Blood sacrifice on distant battlefields that resulted in heroic defeat is a much more romantic national narrative than that offered by Waitangi Day or by increased multiculturalism. And, as my flatmate pointed out, it is overwhelmingly male. I don't wish to sound trite, or to disrespect the young men who lost their lives during this campaign, but what of the women on the home-front - those who raised children or worked for the war effort? What of the working-class men in essential services (during the second world war both of my grandfathers fell into this category - my maternal grandfather, who was a wireless operator, went to Japan as part of the J-Force after the war as part of the occupying force engaged in re-construction rather than destruction)? What of the conscientious objectors who suffered for their pacifist beliefs on the Western Front? In We Will Not Cease, pacifist Archibald Baxter describes how he was subject to 'crucifixion' in No-Man's land for his beliefs. Essentially, that is, left to die by his 'own side'. A new drama - Field Punishment No 1 (2014) - released this year also tells the story of Baxter and 13 other 'conchies'.

Which brings me to why I am writing about Anzac Day on a blog about feminism and motherhood. In Of Women Born, poet Adrienne Rich wrote about the historical role of mothers to 'raise sons for the army' ... and  to raise daughters to continue to produce sons for the army. Women were expected to bring forth life, to continue the species, in order to offer it up for sacrifice at the appropriate moment. To do so, until relatively recently, they risked their health and potentially even their own deaths. In modern terms, 'raising sons for the army' means raising patriarchs, boys who will become men who reproduce - no pun intended - the norms and values of patriarchal culture. Patriarchal culture valorises and commemorates the sacrifice of young men in wars waged by men, and only intermittently recognises the price paid by women or those men who do not conform to patriarchal values.

In every town and city in New Zealand, there are phallic memorials in the centre of town to the young men who died during the First World War. These cenotaphs are the focus of Anzac Day commemorations and the maintenance of the nationalist narratives of blood sacrifice. 

But where, I wonder, are the memorials to the women who 'raised sons for the army'? The women who died in childbirth, of puerperal fever or birth complications? The women who died from botched back-street abortions?  

And, in this moment, when childbirth is much less risky and abortion is, for now, legal and safe, what about the women who suffer and die at the hands of men - usually men they know - every year?  Imagine what might happen if we also said 'lest we forget', heard the melancholy strains of the Last Post, and listened to the words of 'For the Fallen" for them: 

They shall grow not old, as we that are left grow old:
Age shall not weary them, nor the years condemn.
At the going down of the sun and in the morning,
We will remember them.

Next year, it will be 100 years since 1915. 100 years is an arbitrary marker but, no doubt, the centennial commemorations will dwarf even those that have taken place in the past few decades. Will we, I wonder, find room in that spectacle of national commemoration to remember what else patriarchal and nationalist violence entails?







Friday, February 10, 2012

sugar and spice and all things nice

This week, at an indoor playground, I heard the following exchange between two mothers of daughters:


Mother A: I was so glad when I found out I was having a girl. I was like ‘I can plait her hair’ and dress her up in pretty dresses!


Mother B: Oooh, I love the pink tutu skirt she is wearing today!


After my feelings of nausea had passed, I reflected on what I had thought about when I first found out that I was having a girl. It made me conclude that these women and I were very different indeed.


When the radiologist told us that she was ‘99.9% sure’ that we were having a girl, I have to confess that my first reaction was something approaching dread. I hasten to add that was not because I wanted a boy - in the few times that I had imagined myself with a baby in the past, she had always been a girl - but because I suddenly felt an overwhelming sense of responsibility: it would be me who had to teach her how to be a girl and a woman. Again, I hasten to add that this does not mean that I would’ve washed my hands of a boy once he’d passed babyhood, but that I would be her first feminine role model. In my brief moment of dread, I thought about periods, and sex education; I thought about dating and, even worse, not dating (sexual preference to be determined); I thought about body issues, dieting and eating disorders; I thought about the gendered policing of public spaces, unequal pay, and glass ceilings; I thought about overt and covert sexism, and the spectre of sexual assault.


I did not think about pigtails and pinafores.


That may seem surprising given that I kicked off this blog railing against the renaissance of pink baby clothes for girls. But this was a moment or two of quiet dread while I was still pregnant, not the last word on my feelings about mothering a daughter. I think this is perhaps why the passage from Adrienne Rich’s book on the courage of women quoted in my previous post resonated so much with me. It does take courage to be a woman, one who takes her life in her own hands in spite off the things that I listed above, and swims against the current. And it will be me, big chicken that I am, that has to role model this kind of courage for my daughter.


Like I said, a big responsibility. And it gave me new insight into why parents can be so over-protective of their daughters.


But this conversation was not primarily the reason for this post, merely a way in.


Recently, a friend asked me if there were things that were good about having a girl from a feminist point-of-view (as opposed to all the annoying stuff like the pink clothes). She is the mother of a young son and is touched by the warmth and affection between her son and his father, which goes to show that masculine toughness, dominance and suppressed emotion (i.e. how to survive as a male in patriarchy) is learned behaviour.


I struggled with the form of her question for a while, as I found it difficult to separate my daughter’s ‘being-a-girl-ness’ from her own lovely personality. Then I thought I would re-frame the question slightly - hey, it’s my blog and I have the power - to ask ‘what can my daughter enjoy about being a girl before the cultural norms of femininity really take hold?’


Thought about this way, I found it much easier to think of the positive things:


  • her body is a source of endless wonder and fun to her, not a source of insecurity and self-hatred
  • she finds joy in what she can do and learn, not in what she looks like
  • her desire for independence means she wants to try new things for herself and she wants to do it NOW rather than wait for everyone else to have a turn
  • her outbursts of anger are considered healthy and normal reactions to her frustrations with the world around her
  • she receives encouragement and praise from others (not just her parents) when she learns things
  • her boldness and fearlessness in discovering the world around her and how she can interact with it
  • her perseverance in trying new things means she will not give up until she has mastered them
  • her fascination with other girls without feeling any competition with them, nor being judged by them (for the sake of completeness, she is equally fascinated by boys too)


I should note that both my friend’s and my positive things are also, in a sense, negative. They invert stereotypical ideas about masculinity and femininity and show that they are internalised cultural norms that are learned. It doesn’t mean that either of us is off the hook in terms of having to navigate the sharp rocks of gender construction and policing in the future. This will become increasingly tricky through later childhood - children are notoriously strong policers of gender around the ages of 7-8 - and adolescence, when peers, teachers, advertisers and wider society have an increasing say in determining what kind of man and woman our children will become.


For now, however, I am glad that I don’t have a doll for a daughter, and that she is under little compulsion to conform to the cultural imperative of ‘sugar and spice and all things nice’.


Equally, however, I don’t want to her disdain the positive aspects of conventionally feminine behaviour: being in touch with her emotions, being kind and loving, and showing nurturing behaviour towards others. For now, she is all these things too, and I hope we can maintain that balance for as long as possible.


Because, after all, who really wants to be made up of ‘slugs and snails and puppy-dogs’ tails’?



Saturday, January 7, 2012

review: A Life's Work


Rachel Cusk is a Novelist with a capital N.

I can tell this because in her memoir A Life’s Work: On Becoming a Mother (2001) she intersperses moments of genuine insight with dreadfully overwritten prose. Here’s a sample:

I long for my child, long for her as a sort of double, a tiny pilot boat winging young and certain up the channel ahead of me, guiding the blind, clumsy weight of me through. (211)

In my humble opinion, the only thing blind and clumsy about this passage is its use of metaphor. But I’m being merely subjective on aesthetic grounds: others may find narrative like this moving; for me, the only thing moving is my stomach.

More interesting to me were Cusk’s confidences on the vexations and trials of new motherhood: the shock of becoming an unequal partner, the awkwardness of playgroups, and the decidedly un-natural feeling of ‘natural’ processes such as breastfeeding. Every so often, I thought she really crystallised a feeling or an experience that I shared. Like Cusk, I too chafe somewhat at the invisible bonds of motherhood, and sometimes wish for the freedom to just to do my own thing (even if that thing is nothing much at all). Like Cusk, I feel somewhat irritated by responses to this feeling along the lines of ‘yes, but look at what a wonderful baby you have!‘ (as if that was the problem: you can love your child, but still feel constrained by the constant responsibility of looking after them). Here is how Cusk summarises the problem:

Months after the birth I still found myself affronted and incredulous ... by the fact that I could no longer sleep in or watch a film or spend a Saturday morning reading ... The loss of these things seemed a high price to pay for the privilege of motherhood; and though much was given back to me in the form of a daughter it was not payment in kind nor even in a different coin, was not in fact recompense of any sort. My loss and my gain were unrelated, were calculated without the aim of some final, ultimate balance. (144-45)


Of course, in the great scheme of things, losing sleep-ins is not really a huge loss (as compared to, say, the loss of a home, job or life), but it is true that motherhood means that your time is not really your own, unless the baby is asleep or with trusted carers. What I found perceptive about this passage was the idea of loss and gain being unrelated, that they don’t balance out. This formulation highlights that while much is gained that is valued and important - a child, a new experience, new insights and so on - much is also lost - a former self, a former way of life, independence, a career - that is also of value. And it should be okay to mourn that, and cherish its significance. Not to do so, in my view, risks trapping women in the myth of sentimentalised motherhood, and denigrating the experience of women who don’t become mothers.


Cusk gestures elsewhere to broader issues of sexual inequality and motherhood. She comments that ‘childbirth and motherhood are the anvil upon which sexual inequality was forged’ (8) and ‘the biological destiny of women remains standing amidst the ruins of their inequality’ (19) (sidenote: ‘ruins of their inequality’? really?) But these remain cursory gestures at best. Cusk’s persona in this memoir may be ill-at-ease with the narrative of motherhood pre-constructed for her, but her critique remains resolutely at the level of the individual. Rather than take Arminatta Forna’s approach - and that of poet Adrienne Rich, before her - of critiquing the myth and institution of motherhood, Cusk only detours from her anecdotal approach to reconsider literary works such as D H Lawrence’s The Rainbow and Edith Wharton’s The House of Mirth from her new perspective.


Not that there’s anything wrong with taking an idiosyncratic approach: Anne Enright does that too in the fantastic Making Babies. Where Enright and Cusk differ, however, is that Enright does not attempt to offer ‘the truth’ of her individual experience (and she avoids the purple prose too). Enright holds the reader at a distance even as she delves into her most personal experiences. She also avoids the troubling habit that Cusk has of resorting to imperialist and xenophobic metaphors to explain her experiences: Cusk’s newborn baby is likened to ‘a colony’ (95), and her affront at her loss of independence is seen as the result of ‘some foreign and despicable justice’ (144). Similarly, Cusk’s sardonic tales of tried-and-found-wanting babysitters from Brazil, Spain and Slovenia (143-58), appear oblivious to the national, ethnic and class dimensions of the relationship, and appear to position the reader as sharing her privileged exasperation.


This reader didn’t.


Fortunately, a copy of Rich’s Of Woman Born (1972) has arrived for me at the local library. Perhaps that will offer both the personal and political account of motherhood that Cusk so conspicuously lacks.